The Lost Skull – 260 points
| Name | Appearance | Quest | Points | Reward |
| “Yo ho ho … |  |
Complete “The Lost Skull” in less than 8 hours |  |
– |
| … and a bottle of rum” |  |
Complete “The Lost Skull” in less than 2 hours |  |
150  |
| Sharp Cutlasses |  |
Complete “The Lost Skull” while losing fewer than 100 recruits |  |
– |
| Horses Can’t Swim |  |
Complete “The Lost Skull” without using any cavalry | |
– |